It's smaller than I imagined, and there is a brief wait even on a random Tuesday night in fall. But despite our coats, my companion and I quickly find comfort at the bar, where we have a great view of the kitchen action. The menu is unabashedly rich, but the food churned out is well made. They are all familiar flavors that won't surprise you, but they'll be done right. Salmon rillettes are a lovely mix of smoked and fat-poached fish, served with over-buttered toast, dainty pickles, and a delicate little quail egg. It's a great off-the-menu special for cutting through the excess of the rest of the night.
The General Tso's chicken is more Korean, and highly reminiscent of the famed Crisp, though with moister meat and a more gentle, subtle touch. Unfortunately, subtlety is not necessarily something I ask of my fried chicken, and there are a few dry spots. I prefer it to the still-enjoyable Crisp, though it compares less favorably to Lawrence Ave's Great Seas' crispy, punchy, spicy mess of chicken.
Then there are the fries, which I am concerned for A) why they are $10 and B) why it is a popular dish. I blame my companion! In a restaurant that is so reasonably priced (thank you $10 gourmet burgers!), this seems like a sad anomaly. They come with an ultra-thick garlic aioli I could caulk my bathroom with and a mornay, neither of which are more than fine. The egg is not nearly enough to saturate the fries with silky goodness, and the fries are strangely undersalted, though this turns out to be a blessing in disguise. Salt burns can abound even with the most well-seasoned of fries.
But Au Cheval is still a more than pleasant evening. Too pleasant in fact. Our waitress' demeanor starts to turn sour somewhere in the night, and it is only when we are about to leave and check my watch that I realize we've easily gone from lightly lingering to outright camping. Guilt abounds.
Luckily I still have the taste of a scoop of Black Dog Gelato in my mouth, a smooth and silky ball of pure, distilled peppermint, complete with a little pitcher of melted chocolate. Lovely.
So go to Au Cheval. It's a bit of a scene. But when you waddle out, you understand it's not the sort of place to go to when you want to feel good about yourself. Attend a salad bar for that.
3.5 out of 5 stars